Papaya (Carica papaya) is an herbaceous perennial plant native to the tropical Americas. It thrives in tropical and subtropical climates. While the United States is the world’s largest papaya importer, it also cultivates a modest number of papayas, primarily in Hawaii, California, Texas, and Florida. The subtropical climate in Mississippi offers favorable conditions for papaya cultivation. However, frosts in late fall or early spring could pose threats to both plants and fruits. Appropriate cultivar selection and management strategies are critical for successful papaya production in MS. Currently, limited information is available on growing papayas in MS. The objective of this study was to investigate the potential of growing papaya as an alternative crop for specialty crop growers in MS. Preliminary data suggest that papaya plants can grow well in Mississippi. Different cultivars exhibited variations in plant size and vigor. Plants produced papaya fruits with variations in fruit number, size, and shape, as well as timing to fruiting among different cultivars. However, the relatively shorter growing season in MS compared to tropical climates resulted in insufficient time for most fruits to ripen before the onset of frost in late fall. Further research will involve evaluating additional cultivars, adjusting production schedules, employing season extension techniques, and assessing economic feasibility.