Dutch bucket hydroponic systems are used for high-wire crop production such as tomatoes, cucumbers, or peppers, and are typically filled with perlite as a substrate. Through past research, our group identified pine bark and wood fiber as sustainable alternative substrates for high-wire tomato production. Typically, greenhouse tomato growers utilize leachate-based or timed irrigation; however, the use of a water content sensor could precisely identify the irrigation set-point for different substrates, potentially saving water and fertilizers. This study aimed to optimize the irrigation rate for greenhouse tomato ('Favorita F1') production in the Dutch bucket hydroponic system using a soil water content sensor. Three types of substrates (perlite, pine bark, and wood fiber-coir mix (60:40)) and four different gravimetric water contents (100%, 120%, 140%, and 160%) were considered. The experiment was conducted with three replications in a completely randomized design, with the irrigation treatments under the perlite substrate serving as the control. Physical parameters, such as the number of leaves and plant height, were significantly higher in the wood fiber-coir mix and pine bark at 160% irrigation, and lowest under perlite at 100% water content. However, there was no significant difference among the treatments for the number of flower (fruit) clusters. The plant leaf area measurements indicated better vegetative growth with wood fiber-coir mix at 160% water content, whereas pine bark at 160% water content resulted in a higher yield and better fruit quality. In contrast, phytochemicals such as Brix, vitamin C, titratable acidity, lycopene, beta-carotene, and phenolic compounds were significantly higher in the organic substrates (pine bark and wood fiber) with low water content (100% to 120%) and lower in perlite with high water content (140% to 160%). The highest and lowest concentrations of phytochemicals varied between 13% to 67%. There was no significant difference among the treatments (substrates and water contents) in terms of tissue mineral analysis. In general, plants grown in wood fiber-coir mix treatments required 28% and 51% less irrigation compared to those in pine bark and perlite treatments, respectively. Plants grown in organic substrates require less water, and the yield quantity and quality are either similar to or higher than those in perlite. Out of the organic substrates, wood fiber-coir mix can be used in Dutch bucket systems to conserve water and nutrients, enhancing yield quantity and quality, and thereby achieving environmental sustainability.
